Shoe Size Charts Depends on the model

Allen Edmonds Sizing Guide: Do the Boots and Dress Shoes Run Large?

Allen Edmonds boots run large and dress shoes are close to true to size. Learn what each last means and how to size from your Brannock.

By Updated 7 min read

Polished walnut brown leather wingtip dress shoes on a wooden shoeshine stand with a horsehair brush and cloth

Quick answer

Allen Edmonds uses US Brannock sizing. Boots usually run large, so most owners go half a size down from their Brannock size, while classic dress shoes fit close to true to size. The Park Avenue (65 last) is long and narrow: go half a size down or up a width. Sneaker size is only a rough guide.

Fit
Depends on the model
Width
Varies
Our advice
Boots: half a size down from your Brannock. Most dress shoes: your Brannock size. Park Avenue: half down or one width wider.

Allen Edmonds boots tend to run large, and most dress shoes fit close to your Brannock size. A common starting point is half a size down from your Brannock in boots and your Brannock size in classic dress shoes, with the Park Avenue as the main exception: it is long and narrow, so many buyers there go half a size down or up a width.

Unlike some heritage makers, Allen Edmonds works in US sizes and widths from the start, so there is no UK conversion to puzzle over. The real variable is the last, the numbered form the shoe is built around. The guide below sorts the lasts by shape, flags where sources contradict each other, and shows how to turn a Brannock reading or a sneaker size into an order.

Short answer by shoe type

Boots first. Reports on Allen Edmonds boots are consistent enough to call it a pattern: they run large, and half a size down from the Brannock number is the usual correction. Dress shoes are calmer. Most classic models come close to true to size, so order what the Brannock device gave you.

The catch is that the advice is only as good as your measurement. If you have never had your feet measured on a Brannock, do that before anything else. Our guide to measuring your feet covers the home method when no fitting store is near.

Allen Edmonds lasts at a glance

The entries below come from published last descriptions plus owner reports. They are a map, not a lab measurement, and a couple of entries contradict themselves depending on where you read them.

Allen Edmonds lasts: shape and fit character
LastFit characterUsed for or notes
97Average foot, soft slightly pointed toeThe all-rounder
65Long, narrow, elegant, suits higher archesPark Avenue; runs slightly long and narrow
64A slightly roomier 65, more ball room, a bit longerAlternative to the 65
108Longer and narrower, flatter tapered toeSleeker dress shoes
2016Long, narrow, almond toeBest for medium to low arches
511Like the 97 through heel and ball, rounder fuller toeSources conflict: roomy toe in one place, narrow forefoot in another
511GThe 511 with extra depthOrthotics or thick socks
1757Rounder, fuller forefootRoomy in one description, snug heel to toe in another
2321Close to the 1757, slightly narrower toeDress-casual
2622Broad forefoot, round toe, low profile, snug heelLandon
2623Room for a removable insole, softly tapered toeOrthotic-friendly
42NThe 42 with about 3 mm more depthLightForm footbed
APLMore forefoot room, taller toe boxBoots and thick socks
201Higher cone, more instep room, slightly chiseled toeHigher insteps
2072Flatter, low instep, relaxed ballLow-volume feet
2042Fuller forepart, tapered heelLoafers and slip-ons
79Shorter vampLow-cut designs
1943 / 943BSoftly squared toe; 943B has a raised coneTaller boots
2020Subtle toe shelf, streamlined, relaxedModern dress

Where the sources disagree

Two lasts cause most of the confusion. The 511 is called a roomier-toed relative of the 97 in one passage and a narrow-forefoot shoe with a roomy heel and low internal volume in another. The 1757 gets the same split treatment: rounder and fuller on paper, yet snug from heel to toe in one wearer's report on the Higgins Mill.

The likely reason is that fit depends on the model as well as the last. Leather weight, lining and sole construction all change how a last feels on the foot. When you read a review, check which model it describes before you apply the size to yours.

Fit tip: If a last gets mixed reviews, assume it is borderline for your foot shape and order from a seller with an easy return. Allen Edmonds has been reported to offer a 90-day return window on online orders, so check the current terms at checkout.

The Park Avenue and the long-narrow lasts

The Park Avenue sits on the 65, a long and narrow last built for higher arches. The standard advice is to go half a size down, or to keep your size and move up a width. Which of the two is right depends on where the shoe feels tight. If it is the sides of the foot, take the wider width. If you have too much room in front of your toes, take the shorter size.

The 108 and 2016 are in the same family: longer, narrower, tapered or almond toes. Wide-footed buyers tend to be happier in the 97, 64 or one of the rounder lasts. If your forefoot is broad, read our wide feet guide before choosing a dress last at all.

Widths and what is in stock

Allen Edmonds sizes run from US 5 to 16. Widths go from AAAA through EEE: AAAA, AAA, AA, A, B and C count as narrow, D, E and EE as medium, and EEE as wide. A published availability table shows D as the broadest range (about 6 to 16), with the narrowest and widest fittings thinning out at the extremes, such as AAAA starting at 8.5 in the table. The accompanying text implies AAAA is available more broadly, so confirm a particular size before you count on it.

The brand also converts widths for UK shoppers: AAAA equals 4A and EEE equals 3E. For a lookup of the letters against other brands, use our shoe width chart.

Turning your Brannock into an order

Read your Brannock length from the heel-to-toe scale, take the width letter from the ball scale, and measure both feet. Order for the larger one.

  • Boots on a standard last: half a size down from the Brannock, same width.
  • Classic dress shoes (97, 511, 1757 family): your Brannock size, adjusting by width if the shoe feels narrow.
  • Long-narrow lasts (65, 108, 2016): half a size down, or your size in the next width up.
  • Extra-depth lasts (511G, 42N, APL): true to size if you want room for thick socks or an orthotic.

One published fitting report shows how much variation to expect. A wearer with a 9D Brannock who usually takes 8.5D in other heritage boots reported 8.5E in the Higgins Mill, 8.5D in the Landon, and an 8.5D in the Dalton that pinched the forefoot, where the 8.5E fixed the width but let the heel loosen. Same person, three lasts, three answers.

Using your sneaker size

Sneakers are the weakest anchor, because sports brands often print about half a size above the Brannock reading. If you take a men's 10 in Nike or Adidas running shoes, a Brannock of 9.5 is plausible, and in an Allen Edmonds boot half a size down would land at 9. That is arithmetic to sanity-check a number, not a rule. The standard chart below is for reference only.

Standard men's size chart
US men'sUKEUFoot length (cm)CM (JP)
764024.625
7.56.540.524.925.5
874125.426
8.57.54225.926.5
9842.526.227
9.58.54326.727.5
1094427.128
10.59.544.527.528.5
11104527.929
11.510.545.528.429.5
12114628.730
12.511.54729.230.5
131247.529.731

Allen Edmonds labels are US, so this chart matters mainly for UK and EU conversion. One published chart places US 9 at UK 8 and EU 43 for the brand, while the standard chart above shows EU 42.5 for the same US 9, a reminder that EU numbers are approximations. For wider use, see the US to EU conversion guide.

Socks, insoles and break-in

Thick winter socks can justify going up half a size, especially in boots, which sits awkwardly beside the advice to go down half a size in boots. The way to reconcile them is to decide your sock first. If you wear thin dress socks most of the time, take the smaller size. If you want one pair to handle both thin and thick socks, the larger size gives you that range.

On break-in, reports are mixed. One reviewer says the boots needed none, and the same source says structured leather dress shoes can feel snug early on. Both can be true: a soft boot leather and a firm calf dress upper behave differently. A little heel slip at first is normal; a tight toe box or pinching across the ball is not.

Fit tip: Fit shoes late in the day with the sock you will actually wear. The ball of your foot should sit at the widest part of the shoe, and you should see a clean leather crease rather than a deep fold.

Recrafting and where shoes are made

Allen Edmonds is known for Goodyear-welted construction and cork-filled insoles that mold to the foot, which is part of why many owners recraft pairs rather than replace them. Classic welted shoes are made in Port Washington, Wisconsin; the handsewn line is stitched in company-owned factories in the Dominican Republic and finished in Wisconsin, and some newer lines are made in Italy. A size that worked in one line is a good guess rather than a guarantee in another.

In-store master fitters measure heel-to-toe length, arch length and width, which is worth doing once if you can reach a store. For a fit overview that applies across brands, read how dress shoes should fit.

Our recommendation

Get a Brannock reading, identify the last, and apply the rule for that last: half a size down in boots and the long-narrow dress lasts, your Brannock size in most classics. Where the last is one of the contested ones, the 511 or 1757, accept that you may need to exchange once.

Keep a note of the last number, size and width of the pair that finally fits. Next time, you can shop by last instead of starting over.

Frequently asked questions

Do Allen Edmonds shoes run true to size?

Most classic dress shoes come close to your Brannock size. Boots tend to run large, and half a size down is the usual advice. Specific lasts such as the 65 (Park Avenue) run long and narrow, so check the last before you order.

What size Allen Edmonds boot should I buy if I wear a 10 in Nike?

Sneakers often print about half a size above a Brannock reading, so a Nike 10 may be a Brannock 9.5. Half a size down for boots would suggest around a 9. Measure on a Brannock device rather than relying on the sneaker number.

What is the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue last?

The Park Avenue uses the 65 last, described as long, narrow and elegant, and suited to higher arches. Many buyers go half a size down or choose a wider width, depending on whether the shoe is tight at the sides or long in front.

What widths does Allen Edmonds offer?

Sizes run from US 5 to 16 in widths from AAAA to EEE. AAAA to C are narrow, D to EE are medium and EEE is wide. Availability thins at the extremes, so confirm your exact size and width before ordering.

Which Allen Edmonds last is best for orthotics?

The 2623 is described as having room for a removable insole, and the 511G is a 511 with extra depth for orthotics or thick socks. The APL boot last also has a taller toe box for thick socks.

Do Allen Edmonds shoes need breaking in?

It varies by shoe. One reviewer found the boots needed no break-in, but structured leather dress shoes can feel snug at first. Slight heel slip is normal, but pinching across the ball is a sign of a wrong width or size.